Damiana Data
GDP revisions · the long version · Sep 18, 2026

The economy you lived through

The GDP report you heard on the news wasn't the final word.

4:42 video. Every figure in it comes from the checked story data.

What the video says

  1. The GDP report you heard on the news wasn't the final word.

    Since 1965, today's numbers tell a different story about 53 of 244 quarters.

  2. Every quarter since 1965, as it was first measured.

    From Q3 1965 to Q2 2026.

  3. Give every quarter one simple label.

    Was growth above its 10-year average? Was inflation? Growth is real GDP over the past year. Inflation is the GDP price index over the past year, not the consumer price index.

  4. The Philadelphia Fed keeps every version of the data.

    244 vintages, from Q4 1965 to Q3 2026.

  5. Then label each quarter twice.

    Once with the numbers as first published. Once with the numbers as they read today.

  6. If the first numbers were close enough, the two rows would agree.

  7. Here are the quarters that changed label.

    53 of 244, or 21.7%.

    29 changed on growth, 21 on inflation, 3 on both.

  8. Q3 2008: first published, inflation ran above its average.

    First published: 2.7% against 2.4%. Today: 2.1% against 2.3%.

    The examples here were picked after the results were in.

  9. Q1 2019: first published, growth ran well above its average.

    First published: 3.2% against 1.9%. Today: 1.9% against 2.0%.

  10. The changes are not spread evenly.

    The 1970s and 2000s changed most: 13 and 13 quarters.

    Between them they hold 49% of every change.

  11. Recession quarters mostly kept their label.

    4 of 36 changed.

  12. Does the finding survive a change of rule?

    Swap the 10-year average for 5 or 15 years. The share that changed stays between 18% and 22%.

  13. The newest quarter, Q2 2026, reads slower growth, hotter inflation.

    So far it has been published once.

  14. What this does not settle.

    12 of the changes sat within 0.25 percentage points of the average. Labels: ESTIMATED, from one fixed rule. Why the numbers were revised: MISSING.

  15. Where this comes from.

    Federal Reserve Bank of Philadelphia, Real-Time Data Set for Macroeconomists, used for informational, educational and research purposes. National Bureau of Economic Research, US business cycle dates.

Evidence behind it

  • Confirmed: measured and verifiedPublished GDP and pricesCONFIRMED
  • Estimated: modelled or assumed, not measuredRegime labelsESTIMATED
  • Missing: not available or not testedWhy numbers were revisedMISSING

Marks open only as wide as each input’s evidence class allows. See Method.

Method

Source
Federal Reserve Bank of Philadelphia, Real-Time Data Set for Macroeconomists (used for informational, educational and research purposes, per their site terms)
Source
National Bureau of Economic Research, US Business Cycle Expansions and Contractions (copying permitted with attribution)
Scope
regime means only the table in REGIME_RULE_v1.md; inflation is the GDP price index
Scope
what changed, never why; revisions are not errors
Scope
examples were chosen after results were seen and the story says so
Scope
near tie is descriptive, defined after results, not part of the rule
Voice
generated voice, reading the on-screen lines and the lines only spoken
Music
DEX 1200 / Mythical Trees / courtesy of Epidemic Sound

Provenance

resolved story sha256
a5e1759218d1be2d890869a46cbf9a4bfe47df6a19e3858b67a44831413b7051
rendered video sha256
dba51742f128dbfad262729903c4c30609887996ce8505bea21ac433eec96ff1
web video sha256
4fbf5fedc3831f6cdaa5040455b33509a20c637dd6bd65a8cb9d4126898bf478
story data sha256
595818475913dd963c230bd50cda346103d62fa1c5792522c7d9ef282df8004a

Backtests and model estimates on historical data. Not investment advice.